In the same way my nearly unreadable teenage penmanship has devolved across a quarter-century of PC word processing, my natural urge to pause and save a game faded away. I attribute this to the rise of automatic saving, checkpoints, console quick-resume features, and titles where the tension is so high that I instinctively save constantly for fear of catastrophic failure. Yet, I am fallible. I become complacent. And this week, I discovered a vital reminder eight hours into the fresh Switch version of Pokémon FireRed on the Switch: you still gotta smash that save button.
It had been years since I last played a pixel-art Pokémon adventure — as I skipped the Game Boy Advance, the Generation II titles may have been the most recent traditional Pokémon journey I played. So I was pumped to spend $19.99 for the nostalgic return to the Kanto region, and a run gathering those first 151 Pokémon. I quickly returned to my youth. During a handful of gaming sessions, I captured Bug-types, found a Pikachu in Viridian Forest, knocked out Brock on my first turn, gambled on buying the useless fish from the Man at the Pokémon Center, and traversed Mt. Moon carefree and confident.
The problem: I failed to save even once! And never thought to.
Alas, Jigglypuff can never form a bond with my Mankey.
Everything went wrong during a session while I was taking a break from the game… and where my kid grabbed the Switch for a quick half-hour of the latest game instead, quitting my application as a result. As we all know (a fact I foolishly ignored…) opening a new game on the system closes any software running. Your progress is only safe if the game autosaved or after a manual save prior to changing games. Oops.
The Progression of Save Systems: From Deliberate to Seamless
It's fair to consider automatic saving, now so seamless many gamers take it for granted, as a bona fide “cutting-edge” advancement. While PC text adventure Zork had one of the earliest save functions in a game, the original NES Legend of Zelda is widely hailed as a milestone moment because players no longer felt completely screwed following a character's death thanks to persistent memory saves on NES cartridges. Obviously, you still had to remember to save. (And once you erred), it was a mistake made only once. During the nineties, save cards for systems like PlayStation normalized the save process though they were still vulnerable; forgetting to save (or losing a card) could erase countless hours. The survival horror series Resident Evil even turned saving into a scarce commodity.
Today's automatic saving, which suppressed my natural saving reflex my retro gaming session so effectively, gained prominence around the turn of the millennium. The original Halo introduced checkpoint saving whereas later franchises like Call of Duty honed the approach to streamline challenge and reduce tedious replay. As experiences became more vast — and more open-world — developers solved the puzzle on constant background saves and, finally, the ultimate convenience of suspend/resume.
The Pokémon Series' Path: From Conscious Choice to Unconscious Backup
Curiously, the Pokémon series is a great reflection of that historical progression. For a long time, the act of saving your Pokémon journey required a manual command: gamers were conditioned to hit “Save” prior to shutting off their Game Boy or DS. Starting with Pokémon Sword and Shield on Switch, the series introduced an autosave feature (at first as a toggleable option), signaling a significant philosophical change within one of the industry's most slowest-changing series.
I must confess my error: Countless hours spent in Breath of the Wild and recent platformers totally eroded my instinct to save. I am still wary under specific circumstances — I won’t even gamble exiting prematurely in a roguelike despite being aware it saves progress automatically — however, perhaps due to too long since I sank time into a retro-style game, or I’ve just been spoiled, I didn't even think to hit save before putting the console down. My younger self would never have fumbled to this degree.
The Consequences: A Discouraged Player
I have not returned to FireRed since my save debacle. When I saw the title screen again to see I had only my starter Squirtle, a wave of exhaustion hit me. My personal status: Burned.
I might give it another shot… or maybe I’ll stick with the hundreds of new games available now that operate under the assumption I need my hand held. However, my love for retro gaming persists. During times I can distract my kid to pause her current favorite, we have been cooperatively playing a collection of classic Bomberman games. Those early SNES games had no save system at all in favor of lengthy password codes. So, even if I blow myself up, the setback is minimal. For now, that’s comfort.